Spaghetti al PomodoroMax SoHa · Morningside Heights, New York CityOn 50+ listsSave Spaghetti al Pomodoro
Spaghetti MeatballsNonna Dora’s Pasta Bar · Kips Bay, New York CityOn 25+ listsSave Spaghetti Meatballs
Fettuccine with Buffalo ButterMisi · Williamsburg, New York CityOn 25+ listsSave Fettuccine with Buffalo Butter
Rigatoni with Vodka SauceEmilio’s Ballato · Nolita, New York CityOn 25+ listsSave Rigatoni with Vodka Sauce
Baked Clams OreganataOld Homestead Steakhouse · Meatpacking District, New York CityOn 10+ listsSave Baked Clams Oreganata
Spinach Ricotta PizzaKoronet Pizza · Morningside Heights, New York CityOn 10+ listsSave Spinach Ricotta Pizza
Pappardelle al CinghialeFiaschetteria Pistoia · West Village, New York CityOn 10+ listsSave Pappardelle al Cinghiale
Tagliatelle al TartufoFiaschetteria Pistoia · West Village, New York CityOn 10+ listsSave Tagliatelle al Tartufo
Maccheroni sull'AnatraFiaschetteria Pistoia · West Village, New York CityOn 10+ listsSave Maccheroni sull'Anatra
Chicken Milanese SandwichDaily Provisions · Union Square, New York CityOn 5+ listsSave Chicken Milanese Sandwich
Pici Freschi Cacio e PepeFiaschetteria Pistoia · West Village, New York CityOn 5+ listsSave Pici Freschi Cacio e Pepe
Sformatino di ZucchineFiaschetteria Pistoia · West Village, New York CityOn 5+ listsSave Sformatino di Zucchine
Uovo al Tartufo NeroFiaschetteria Pistoia · West Village, New York CityOn 5+ listsSave Uovo al Tartufo Nero
Chitarra with Braised LambMisi · Williamsburg, New York CityOn 5+ listsSave Chitarra with Braised Lamb
Margherita PieTotonno’s Pizzeria Napolitana · Coney Island, New York CityOn 5+ listsSave Margherita Pie
Pappardelle al RagùFiaschetteria Pistoia · West Village, New York CityOn 5+ listsSave Pappardelle al Ragù
Polpette al Sugo con PolentaRoscioli · SoHo, New York CityOn 5+ listsSave Polpette al Sugo con Polenta
Fried Calamari and ZucchiniChadwick’s · Bay Ridge, New York CityOn 5+ listsSave Fried Calamari and Zucchini
Mozzarella SticksJohn’s of Bleecker Street · West Village, New York CityOn 5+ listsSave Mozzarella Sticks
Tiramisu Mille CrêpesLady M Cake Boutique · Midtown, New York CityOn 5+ listsSave Tiramisu Mille Crêpes
Arancini with Kabocha SquashFausto · Park Slope, New York CityOn 5+ listsSave Arancini with Kabocha Squash
Buffalo StracciatellaManhatta · Financial District, New York CityOn 5+ listsSave Buffalo Stracciatella
Grandma Pie with Broccoli RabeLuigi’s Pizza · Park Slope, New York CityOn 5+ listsSave Grandma Pie with Broccoli Rabe
Mafaldini with Pink PeppercornLilia · Williamsburg, New York CityOn 3+ listsSave Mafaldini with Pink Peppercorn
Gnocchi al Ragù di SalsicciaFiaschetteria Pistoia · West Village, New York CityOn 3+ listsSave Gnocchi al Ragù di Salsiccia
Grilled Portuguese OctopusPortofino Ristorante · Forest Hills, New York CityOn 3+ listsSave Grilled Portuguese Octopus
Involtini di Pesce SpadaGennaro · Upper West Side, New York CityOn 3+ listsSave Involtini di Pesce Spada
Italian Wedding SoupCafe Fiorello · Upper West Side, New York CityOn 3+ listsSave Italian Wedding Soup
Maine Lobster Spaghetti a la ScampiThe Eighty Six · West Village, New York CityOn 3+ listsSave Maine Lobster Spaghetti a la Scampi
Milk Ricotta CheesecakeSaraghina Bakery · Bed-Stuy, New York CityOn 3+ listsSave Milk Ricotta Cheesecake
Original Matcha TiramasuCha-An Teahouse · East Village, New York CityOn 3+ listsSave Original Matcha Tiramasu
Ricotta Gnocchi with Broccoli PestoLilia · Williamsburg, New York CityOn 3+ listsSave Ricotta Gnocchi with Broccoli Pesto
Sheep's Milk Cheese AgnolottiLilia · Williamsburg, New York CityOn 3+ listsSave Sheep's Milk Cheese Agnolotti
Sheep's milk ricotta filled occhiMisi · Williamsburg, New York CityOn 3+ listsSave Sheep's milk ricotta filled occhi
Spinach and mascarpone filled tortelliMisi · Williamsburg, New York CityOn 3+ listsSave Spinach and mascarpone filled tortelli
Antipasto Freddo Della CasaPasquale’s Rigoletto · Belmont, New York CitySave Antipasto Freddo Della Casa
Baked Rigatoni alla VodkaCafe Spaghetti · Carroll Gardens, New York CitySave Baked Rigatoni alla Vodka
Black Linguine with Shrimp & CalamariUmberto’s Clam House · Little Italy, New York CitySave Black Linguine with Shrimp & Calamari
Caesar Salad Pizza with ChickenCorato I Pizza & Restaurant · Ridgewood, New York CitySave Caesar Salad Pizza with Chicken
Cavatelli with Sausage and Browned Sage ButterFrankies 457 Spuntino · Carroll Gardens, New York CitySave Cavatelli with Sausage and Browned Sage Butter
Charred Marinated Peppers with Whipped RicottaMisi · Williamsburg, New York CitySave Charred Marinated Peppers with Whipped Ricotta
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana HeroTino’s Delicatessen · Belmont, New York CitySave Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Hero
Crostini of Smoked Hake ConservaRoman’s · Fort Greene, New York CitySave Crostini of Smoked Hake Conserva
Dry Aged Porterhouse MeatballsQuality Meats · Midtown, New York CitySave Dry Aged Porterhouse Meatballs
Emilia's Special AntipastoEmilia’s Restaurant · Belmont, New York CitySave Emilia's Special Antipasto
Fresh Mozzarella PizzaCorato I Pizza & Restaurant · Ridgewood, New York CitySave Fresh Mozzarella Pizza
Fusilli with Octopus and Bone MarrowMarea · Midtown, Las VegasNewSave Fusilli with Octopus and Bone Marrow
Garlic Maine Lobster TailRed Hook Lobster Pound · Red Hook, New York CitySave Garlic Maine Lobster Tail
Gnocchi Sardi with Pork Sausage SugoMisi · Williamsburg, New York CitySave Gnocchi Sardi with Pork Sausage Sugo
Grandma Ann's Homemade Italian CheesecakeAnn & Tony’s · Belmont, New York CitySave Grandma Ann's Homemade Italian Cheesecake
John’s Meatball SandwichJohn’s of Bleecker Street · West Village, New York CitySave John’s Meatball Sandwich